Tips, Tricks & Techniques
Basic Grilling:
How to “Save” a Disaster!
This is not going to be a post that gives you a magic bullet for every disaster that could befall you when cooking out doors on a grill. I won’t be writing anything about flare-ups, grease fires or other problems that occur when you are cooking. I’m going to write a few suggestions about how to save a meal that has gone from bad to horrible and you have a table with hungry guests!
Here are some useful tips I’ve learned by experience that just might save a meal when you are in a pinch and something bad happens. As with any “safety tip” – it’s useful to practice the drill when you aren’t in an emergency situation so you know what to do when it does occur!
PROBLEM – Burned Chicken
This happens quite often to backyard griller’s. The first preventative tip is “don’t use sugar-based sauces or marinades on food prior to placing it on the grill!” The sugar burns when exposed to the direct heat of grilling. The second preventative tip is most applicable to charcoal users – let the charcoal burn down until white ash covers them and bank the charcoal to one side or the other so you use more indirect heat. But let’s suppose you have forgotten this and have a grill full of burned chicken parts and you are stuck!
CB’s EZ TIP – How to Save Burned Chicken
Remove the burned skin. This will get rid of most of the carbon material. Then “very lightly” sauce the skinned cooked chicken with a tomato-based bbq sauce (ketchup can work mixed with Worcestershire and a little brown sugar) -OR- make a sauce by combining a apple cider vinegar and brown sugar -OR- lemon juice and brown sugar -OR- apple juice and brown sugar -OR- Coca-Cola and brown sugar -OR- DR. Pepper and brown sugar.
What your are trying to do is mix up a sweet & sour combination that will counteract the burned material and actually make it a better taste.
I recommend you actually try this with a “sacrificial” piece of chicken the next time you grill – just to get a sense of what taste you like and wish to serve.
PROBLEM – Tough and/or Dry Meat
Cutting across the grain of all meats is the recommended method for all roasts, steaks, etc. This ‘cuts’ the muscle fibers and makes chewing less difficult or more pleasurable - even on perfectly cooked cuts of flank steak, etc. – depending upon the serving of meat. But let’s say you got to talking with your neighbors and overcooked the steaks, chops or a roast and now are faced with the embarrassment of presenting dry and tough meat on the plate!
CB’s EZ TIP – How to Save Tough Meat
This works with tough beef and pork, but can be useful with large chicken or turkey breasts that have been overcooked to the dry point as well.
Use the sharpest knife you have and slice the meat across the grain into “extremely” thin slices. Then add a touch of bbq sauce that is ‘watered down’ with water, beer, beef or chicken stock and toss. The thin slices will make the toughness seemingly disappear (or most of it) and a light touch of sauce will moisten but not overwhelm the meat.
PROBLEM – Undercooked Meat
We’ve all served up a beautiful plate of grilled meat and the first bite by the mother-in-law results in a horrible phrase uttered from her “It’s raw.” OK – it may not actually be raw, but she has a look on her face that says you just tried to poison her and her daughter never should have married you in the first place. What do you do? Most folks say things like – “Oh gosh, let me put that back on the grill for you!” And then mom-in-law sits there poking at her potato salad with the look of martyrdom that translates into unspeakable retribution to you. Actually putting slightly undercooked meat back on the grill, if it’s still very warm, is the best method.
But let’s say the meat has been covered and sitting on the buffet table for a while and it’s cooled down – what then? Placing partially cooked and cooled food back on the grill to cook the center is not going to deliver the results you want – because the outside will need to heat up and conduct heat to the center – that means you will now serve an overcooked surface with barely cooked middle.
CB’s EZ TIP – How to Save Under Cooked Meat #1
Since placing partially cooked food back on the grill will result in overcooked surface and barely cooked middle – the safest bet, if you are home, is to place the food in the microwave and give it a couple of 15-20 second blasts. This will excite the moisture in the meat and heat it up. I know I know – how could I say such a thing! Hey, this is an emergency. Believe it or not some of your favorite restaurants use this trick. Just don’t over do it!
CB’s EZ TIP – How to Save Under Cooked Meat #2
Remember the tough meat tip? Same goes for undercooked meat. If it’s a roast, slice it thin and place it on a heated tray resting on the grill – for just a few minutes – to kinda “fry” it. If you are afraid of over frying it, add a light touch of bbq sauce to the meat. Or even a bit of water – to kinda steam it quickly. This technique will quickly cook the raw piece and not over cook it…but you have to pay attention!
CB’s EZ TIP – How to Save Under Cooked Meat #3
You’ll need to use a moisture bath to gently warm up slices. This can be water, beer, broth, bbq sauce, etc. You don’t want to cook it in the liquid – but just warm it so it’s not raw.
NEXT TIME – be prepared with an instant read thermometer and know the USDA guideline temperature chart by memory to ensure you cook the center of foods. Also make sure, except for hamburgers, you don’t cook food on the grill directly from the cooler or fridge. Cooking cold food will result in a cooked exterior with cold or undercooked interiors.
HEY CB! What about chicken that’s raw in the middle???
First of all, please consider my tips for cooking chicken that are in various recipes and posts on this site. (Lower Left-Hand Column – search for the word ‘Chicken’) I recommend the best way to cook chicken is to let it warm up a bit after taking it out of the cooler or fridge. You can do this on the counter at home or even a low-low-low 200 degree oven or cooker to slowly bring it to temperature for grilling. Grilling as the only method of preparing cold chicken will usually result in overcooked outside with undercooked insides. So use direct heat for searing and indirect heat for finishing. And please use an instant read thermometer to check the internal temperature. Finished chicken should be at about 165F degrees internal temperature after holding for 10 – 15 minutes, before serving.
CB’s EZ TIP – How to Save Undercooked Chicken
Place the chicken pieces on an oven-safe tray, place a small oven-safe cup in the middle of the tray and fill it half way with warmed water, beer or white wine. “Tent” the chicken and tray with aluminum foil – making sure the edges are tight and there is a bit of room between the foil and the chicken, so steam can escape from the cup. Place the entire tray on the grill and close the lid. If you are using charcoal…make sure the heat is directly under the tray. If using gas, the heat should be on low.
The water will steam the chicken, helping to keep the surface from drying out, and the heat from the tray with the hot air inside the ‘foil tent’ will roast the chicken. This may take a few minutes but the results are not going to be overcooked chicken surfaces.
What’s your best tip for saving a disaster? I encourage you to share your story and maybe with the solutions you came up with. Just click on the word Comment, directly below. [NOTE: your first comment doesn't immediately appear until I review it.]
Happy Grilling!










